Sludge Report #192: The Naked Budget   20 May 2010

Alastair Thompson

Column - C.D. Sludge


Sludge Report #192: The Naked Budget


By Alastair Thompson


Click for big version

Its All About Tax - GST Rises & Tax Cuts For All

Finance Minister Bill English's second budget is an exercise in minimalism in everything but tax. And in that respect the changes announced today have been so well flagged that there is little news today besides the sweeping income tax cuts which will take effect from 1 October. Tax cuts for all!

Business tax too will drop from 33% to 28% come 1 April 2011 - coming in comfortably two years ahead of similar company tax cuts across the ditch.

Balancing the income tax cuts is the expected rise in GST to 15%. The Government expects this to only result in a modest 2% increase in CPI inflation and it will compensate beneficiaries and super-annuitants with an across the board 2.02% increase in payments.

Meanwhile forecast annual growth of 3% per annum for the next four years means the scary debt mountain scenarios painted this time last year have now disappeared from forecasts.

In the Budget 2010 media kit fully half of the material released today relates to the tax changes. Fact sheets detail the impacts of the GST rise, the income tax cuts, compensation for low income earners, changes to rules to stop the wealthy accessing working for families, and sundry related - but relatively significant - technical changes implementing changes to depreciation rules and thin capitalisation rules applying to multinationals.

Notably missing from the budget is the promised move to rebalance the investment environment away from a bias towards rental property investment. The depreciation changes do address this area - but only at the margins and are unlikely to have any real impact on the great New Zealand love affair with real estate investment.

Also missing is any mention of superannuation or indications of timing for a resumption in contributions to the Cullen New Zealand Superannuation fund.

Tax Cuts For The Rich?

The headline for the opposition is writ large - and is already in play thanks to the Government making its intentions pretty obvious in recent days.

The drop in the top marginal tax rate - for income over $70,000 from 38% to 33% - rewards an important constituency of the National Party voters where it matters most.

Meanwhile the GST rise is regressive, hitting the poor and vulnerable harder than the wealthy.

From 1 October an earner on $120,000 a year will be getting $90 more a week in the hand vs an earner on $48,000 getting an extra $28 a week. After the GST clawback is taken into account the relative improvement in fortunes is $56 a week vs $13 a week.

But Bill English clearly has a plan to counter the tax cuts for the rich argument and spent a fair bit of his lockup presentation laying this out:
1) everybody is getting a tax cut;
2) two thirds of cost of the tax cuts goes into reducing the lowest two tax rates;
3) families in the middle income brackets have proportionately had the biggest tax cuts over the past 14 years;
4) compensation is being provided to beneficiaries for the GST increase.

Mr English tellingly pointed to a graph (see below) showing the relative levels of tax cuts in percentage terms across the income scale over the past 14 years (since 1996).

 


Click for big version

The graph shows that income earners in the $40k to $60k range have received the largest falls over this period and in presenting the slide Mr English indicated he approved wholeheartedly of this. Implicit in this was a vote of approval in the economic policies of the previous government and in all but one respect (i.e. financing them through a rise in GST) this is a set of tax cuts which might have been introduced by Michael Cullen.

In answer to a question from TV3s' John Campbell on the subject English said the changes were not, "hairy chested large scale change" - and they clearly aren't. In many ways they seem relatively sophisticated and sensitive. And in a sense you could almost see them as a completion of the tax reform programme undertaken by the previous government.

Asked by TVNZ's Guyon Espiner whether this was part of a programme of tax cuts with more to come in the future Mr English said no. There was a possibility of more changes to come, but "this is likely to be the biggest change we are making". In other words this completes the rebalancing.

And perhaps hinting a little at another motivation for this move Mr English concluded his Q&A remarking: "We [NZ] are open for business and ready to go, and compared to everybody else [other nations] we are in great shape".

Economic Outlook Significantly More Confident

And it is definitely true that overall the fiscal position outlined in this budget has improved dramatically.

 


Click for big version

The economy is bouncing back faster than expected and consequently where last year we were looking at fiscal deficits throughout the outlook period and massive indebtedness in 20 years time - the current forecast sees the NZ economy coming back into surplus in 2016 with - in global terms - a fairly comfortable looking balance sheet.

And the government is hoping it can achieve that even earlier.

That said there may be little bit of pollyanna in forecasts which show a NZ economy achieving consistent growth of 3% over the coming three years during a period when global debt markets are seemingly again on the precipice of another meltdown.

Beyond the Tax Cuts

When you look deeper into the budget - on the spending side - you find that with this Finance Minister less is most definitely less. The government has found enough cash to prevent the health system going into cardiac arrest - and some crumbs to throw at education and that's about it.

The additional health funds $500 million a year will not be enough to actually relieve pressure in the health system, but should be enough to prevent it hemorrhaging - something which has in recent months been looking like a distinct possibility. The CTU forecast was that in order to flat-line NZ's health system needed an increase of $550 million a year - its received an increase of $512 million.

Tertiary education funding has been topped up to actually pay for the additional students who are already enrolled (but at present are not actually being paid for) - and free early childhood education funding remains in place. Money has been saved by changing the rules so that those centers who were expecting to get increased funding to pay for fully qualified workforces won't be getting it. This seems likely to mean that the best ECE centers will have to increase their part charges or hire some non-qualified staff at lower rates to balance their own budgets. However the policy of 20 hours of ECE remains substantially in place - as do interest free student loans.

On the infrastructure investment side the Government appears to have reannounced a lot of spending that they have already announced and while there is definitely a large investment underway in roading - the rest of the programme is probably not as generous or as economically forward thinking as you might be led to believe. For example $200 million for broadband vs $337 million for prisons.

The other area of actual investment in the budget is research and science which has received $300 odd million over four years.

The Crumbs

In coalition government terms there are some additional wins for ACT and the Maori Party.

ACT gets its economic think tank - the Productivity Commission - which looks broadly similar to the Families Commission that United Future got out of the last Labour Government, i.e. a standalone external group of policy wonks who will likely be ignored.

Funding for this - as with most other new initiatives being announced, e.g. some cycle tracks being built by the Department of Conservation - will come out of existing budgets. The productivity Commission release says that its funding will come out of 29 different existing budgets.

The Maori Party's big win this budget was Whanau Ora - which remains almost as opaque as it did when announced. In addition there is a few million for Maori economic development and a pilot prison rehabilitation scheme for Maori offenders in Auckland and Hawke's Bay. However the scale of funding involved in this - $5 million a year - gives a fairly strong indication of its likely impact.

The Naked Budget

 


Click for big version

Budget 2010 is good politics well managed. Tax cuts for all will be the headline, and the business community and core National Party constituency have received their payoff and will be left happy.

The most odious and unpopular part of the programme will be the GST rise, but in media terms the pre-announcement of this before Christmas has effectively minimised it, the GST debate is now old news.

The tax cut package will also be a hit with financial markets - as Mr English says, to be cutting taxes while the rest of the OECD is reeling from fiscal shocks looks pretty impressive. And there is a possibility that the cuts may assist with economic growth if by no other means than simply by boosting confidence.

But it is also fairly clear looking inside these cuts (73% of earners will have a top tax rate of 17.5%) that NZers basically need to earn more if we are to make any real economic progress. And this is the long term goal which the Government cannot yet afford to pursue.

And as for the rest - its basically all tinkering. The social spending framework put in place by the Labour Party remains in place - well subsidised primary health care, free early childhood education, interest free student loans, working for families. Even the ongoing expansion of health spending remains intact. What Labour gave has not been taken away - yet.

So this is a second budget which is calculated not to scare the horses and to ensure maximum chances of re-election in 2011. The tax cuts give the impression of progress but look underneath and they are basically a transfer of taxation burden away from the wealthy to the working classes.

The main question which remains - given that we have stopped funding the National Super Fund and have cut revenues at a time when we already have large deficits - is will a privatisation agenda be a key component of a second term National Government?

ENDS

Add a comment

Bookmark and Share

News

Details of The Duke of Cambridge’s visit announced

18 Apr 2019 News By RT HON JACINDA ARDERN
18 APRIL 2019 Details of His Royal Highness The Duke of Cambridge’s itinerary for his upcoming visit to New Zealand on 25th... more

NZ and France seek to end use of social media for acts of terrorism

24 Apr 2019 News By RT HON JACINDA ARDERN
New Zealand and France announced today that the two nations will bring together countries and tech companies in an attempt to bring to... more

Business

Minister Parker leads trade delegation to China

24 Apr 2019 Business News By Hon David Parker
Minister for Trade and Export Growth David Parker will lead a delegation of business representatives to China next week to advance the... more

Multinationals to pay fair share of tax

26 Jun 2018 Business News
26 JUNE 2018 HON STUART NASH New measures to ensure multinational companies pay their fair share of tax will come into force next... more

Living

Kiwis Saving Kiwi - London fundraiser to save NZ's iconic national bird

3 Jun 2019 London
This is an opportunity for London Kiwis to become Kiwi Savers. We're not talking about our financial future here, but the very... more

Celebrating NZ wine: today is International Sauvignon Blanc Day!

3 May 2019 Food & Wine
Today, Friday 3 May, is International Sauvignon Blanc Day. Sauvignon Blanc is the variety that woke the world up to New Zealand wine,... more

Property

New Zealand Government will not implement a Capital Gains Tax

17 Apr 2019 Property By RT HON JACINDA ARDERN
The Coalition Government will not proceed with the Tax Working Group’s recommendation for a capital gains tax, Jacinda Ardern... more

More certainty in construction sector smooths boom and bust cycle

22 Aug 2018 Property
30 JULY 2018More certainty in construction sector smooths boom and bust cycle HON JENNY SALESA The 2018 National Construction Pipeline... more

Migration

Christchurch reinstated as refugee settlement location

18 Aug 2018 Migration
18 AUGUST 2018 HON IAIN LEES-GALLOWAY The announcement that Christchurch can once again be a settlement location for refugees... more

Post-study work rights emphasise skills NZ needs

8 Aug 2018 Migration
8 AUGUST 2018 HON IAIN LEES-GALLOWAY Changes to post-study work rights will help ensure international students coming to New Zealand... more

Travel

Arrival card change to smooth border process for international travellers to NZ

26 Sep 2018 Travel & Tourism By Hon Kris Faafoi
25 SEPTEMBER 2018 International travellers arriving into New Zealand should have a simpler, faster entry as a result of changes to... more

NZ Government to fully fund Auckand's SkyPath as part of $390m investment in walking and cycling

25 Aug 2018 Travel & Tourism
23 AUGUST 2018 HON PHIL TWYFORD HON JAMES SHAW Transport Minister Phil Twyford and Acting Associate Transport Minister James Shaw have... more

Sport

America’s Cup court ruling vindicates process

26 Sep 2018 Sailing By Hon David Parker
25 SEPTEMBER 2018 The Environment Court has today granted the resource consent for the 36th America's Cup bases in Auckland and the... more

Humble Stephen Kearney praises Warriors staff ahead of finals appearance: 'It's not down to one person'

3 Sep 2018 Rugby League
Warriors coach Stephen Kearney paid tribute to the club's unsung heroes ahead of their first taste of NRL finals football since... more

Columns

Gordon Campbell on the Gareth Morgan crusade

11 Nov 2016 Opinion
Gordon Campbell on the Gareth Morgan crusade First published on Werewolf The ghastly likes of Marine Le Pen in France and Geert ... more

Gordon Campbell on the US election outcome

10 Nov 2016 Opinion
Column - Gordon Campbell   Gordon Campbell on the US election outcome Well um.. on the bright side, there (probably)... more

Kiwi Success

Congratulations to Loder Cup winner

26 Sep 2018 People By Hon Eugenie Sage
25 SEPTEMBER 2018 The Loder Cup, one of New Zealand’s oldest conservation awards, has been awarded to Robert McGowan for 2018... more

Appointments to New Zealand National Commission for UNESCO

16 Aug 2018 Appointments
16 AUGUST 2018Appointments to New Zealand National Commission for UNESCO HON JENNY SALESA Associate Education Minister Jenny Salesa is... more

Recruitment

Historic pay equity settlement for education support workers

14 Aug 2018 Recruitment By RT HON JACINDA ARDERN
14 AUGUST 2018Historic pay equity settlement for education support workers RT HON JACINDA ARDERN HON CHRIS HIPKINS Prime Minister The... more

Historic pay equity settlement for education support workers

22 Aug 2018 Recruitment By RT HON JACINDA ARDERN
14 AUGUST 2018Historic pay equity settlement for education support workers RT HON JACINDA ARDERN HON CHRIS HIPKINS Prime Minister The... more