Gordon Campbell on the asset sales referendum victory   3 Sep 2013

Column - Gordon Campbell


Gordon Campbell on the asset sales referendum victory

by Gordon Campbell

All credit to Grey Power and the Greens for getting across the sky high threshold required to trigger a Citizens Initiated Referendum (CIR) on the asset sales programme. It has been a remarkable organizational feat, given the number of signatures required, in the time frame stipulated. Not surprisingly the Prime Minister John Key has already gone on the attack against this exercise of grass roots democracy – calling it an “utter waste of money” that will not be held until the asset sales process is virtually over. Which is a bit rich, given that mindful of the need for urgency, Key has it entirely in his power to bring the referendum forwards, such that it would be more meaningful. His own government seems more than willing to ram legislation through Parliament under urgency whenever it suits him.

Also, other organs of our democracy – such as the Supreme Court – speedily adjusted their timetables so as to grant an early hearing to the Maori water rights case, and thus not affect the planned timing of the government’s asset sales process. Yet when the shoe is on the other foot –ie, when the public wants to have its say - Key’s first reaction is to pull back on the levers of government and delay, apparently in order to render the referendum more ineffectual and thereby turn his predictions of a low turnout into a self-fulfilling prophecy. Perhaps Key needs to re-read his stirring attack on the Clark government’s handling of the CIR process over the 2008 referendum on the section 59 child discipline law.

National Party leader John Key said Helen Clark was "arrogantly out of touch" and "running scared" on the issue. “Her government does not like the New Zealand public being able to express their view on democracy. They are about to be stopped from being able to exercise their democratic view through a referendum on the anti-smacking legislation at the election ... Why does the Prime Minister not just admit she finds the voters of New Zealand an annoyance?"

Why the arrogance, indeed. This referendum will be on an issue far more crucial to wider issues of fairness, competence, income equality and national wellbeing than the poll on the “right” of parents to use violence against their children in the name of good parenting, allegedly on Biblical authority. Not that this referendum doesn’t have a Biblical ring to it as well – it is about prising the hands of the money changers off of our assets.

Key cannot use the “waste of money” argument either, not with a straight face. When his government wants to fling money at the asset sales process, he never gives it a second thought. Thrift has gone out the window over the unloading these assets. So far, the meter is ticking over at an estimated $115 million bill for the managing of an asset sales programme already unlikely to break even before these extra costs were racked up. The dismal performance of Mighty River shares since the share float earlier this year is also reason to pause and seek a further mandate from us, the owners – before Key begins to unload more of our energy companies onto a sharemarket already crowded with them.

The argument that Key has already received a mandate at the last election and doesn’t need to bother about the CIR result strikes me as entirely perverse. Surely, the notion is indefensible that democracy begins and ends on Election Day, whatever comes to light afterwards, and whatever expressions of public disquiet subsequently surface. In this case, getting well over 300,000 people (in a country of little over four million) to sign a petition in a short space of time is an indication that a very significant level of public disquiet exists with respect to the government going ahead with the unloading of their assets. We are not talking about overturning the wider mandate - this is not a referendum on changing the government, but merely a referendum on one important plank of its programme. One that affects assets that we own. The idea that we cannot revisit any policy between elections (because otherwise the sky would fall?) seems absurd. The CIR hurdle has been set high enough that such a revisiting cannot be done on a whim.

Nor need it be mandatory that the result be implemented. In a healthy democracy though, the government would take heed of its outcome, and bear the consequences at the next election of ignoring it. Bad mouthing the process – or worse, treating the process, rather than the government’s ill tempered response as the main problem – seems a bizarre reaction. To repeat: the cost involved in holding a CIR poll is minimal in comparison to routine examples of government waste, and when compared to the routine cost of the state’s public relations machinery. This is value for money, as a form of public debate and participatory democracy. All we need now is for the government to participate in it, and hold the referendum ASAP.


Add a comment

Bookmark and Share


Dynamic New Zealand writers to feature at this year’s Edinburgh International Book Festival

20 Jul 2017 Arts
Dynamic New Zealand writers making waves at home and abroad will present their work and participate in this year’s Edinburgh... more

$9.4m to support students with English as a second language

26 Jun 2017 Education
22 June 2017 Students learning English as a second language will benefit from a further $9.4 million being made available under... more


Rocket launch a huge step for New Zealand’s space industry

25 May 2017 Business News
25 May 2017 Minister for Economic Development Simon Bridges has congratulated the team at Rocket Lab on the successful launch of... more

Increased investor confidence welcomed

29 May 2017 Business News
29 May 2017 Commerce and Consumer Affairs Minister Jacqui Dean today welcomed the Financial Markets Authority annual survey results... more


NZ's Sola Rosa heading "Back to You" in London - interview with Andrew Spraggon

6 Jul 2017 Entertainment By Charlotte Everett
Sola Rosa Soundsystem heads back to London with a show on 27 July – NZNewsUK London Editor Charlotte Everett caught up with... more

Spirit of “Mateship” prominent at London ANZAC commemorations

25 Apr 2017 ANZAC By Charlotte Everett
All photos copyright Peter Livingstone Photography. Lead image: HRH The Duke of York (far right), with the Hon Alexander Downer (far... more


New Zealand Housing Affordability Measure released

10 May 2017 Property
10 May 2017 The Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment’s (MBIE) new Housing Affordability Measure will allow the market... more

NZ house prices gain 11% in October

14 Nov 2016 Property
Article - BusinessDesk Monday 14 November 2016 10:28 AM NZ house prices gain 11% in October, driven by sales of higher value homes By... more


Suspension of decision making authority

25 Apr 2017 Migration
24 April 2017Immigration Minister Michael Woodhouse is taking steps to improve Immigration New Zealand’s decision making... more

Recognised Seasonal Employers employ more Kiwis

8 Feb 2017 Migration
7 Feb 2017 Immigration Minister Michael Woodhouse welcomes a report showing the vast majority of employers who take on seasonal... more


International visitors projected to spend $15 billion

12 May 2017 Travel & Tourism
12 May 2017 New Zealand’s tourism sector is forecast to grow significantly over the next seven years, with international... more

Tourism spending continues rise in 2017

10 May 2017 Travel & Tourism
27 April 2017 Tourism spending by both international and domestic visitors continues to grow strongly in 2017, Acting Tourism Minister... more


SPECIAL LIMITED OFFER: Barbarians v NZ, Twickenham 4 Nov - £55 tickets, All Blacks Supporters Bay

20 Jul 2017 Rugby
In 2009 the Barbarian team had a phenomenal line up of world class players; Matt Giteau, Victor Matfield, George Smith, Jamie Roberts,... more


Gordon Campbell on the Gareth Morgan crusade

11 Nov 2016 Opinion
Column - Gordon Campbell   Gordon Campbell on the Gareth Morgan crusade First published on Werewolf more

Gordon Campbell on the US election outcome

10 Nov 2016 Opinion
Column - Gordon Campbell   Gordon Campbell on the US election outcome more

Kiwi Success

Law Commissioner appointed

29 May 2017 Appointments
29 May 2017 Former Secretary for Justice Belinda Clark has been appointed as Law Commissioner, Justice Minister Amy Adams announced... more

Spencer to be Acting Governor of Reserve Bank

8 Feb 2017 Appointments
7 Feb 2017 Finance Minister Steven Joyce will appoint current Deputy Reserve Bank Governor Grant Spencer as the Acting Governor of... more


Online job ads continue growing strongly

26 Jun 2017 Recruitment
23 June 2017 Tertiary Education, Skills and Employment Minister Paul Goldsmith says the latest Jobs Online report shows strong growth... more

New employment resource for young people

1 Mar 2017 Recruitment
28 Feb 2017 Tertiary Education, Skills and Employment Minister Paul Goldsmith and Associate Education Minister Louise Upston have... more