Gordon Campbell on the incentive payments at ACC 22 Jun 2012
- Open data benefits public and economy News
- New IRD office shows Government’s commitment to Christchurch News
- NZ seeks all-of-government banking proposals Business
- NZ regulators starts money laundering monitoring this month Business
- Solid Energy leaves Mataura briquette plant with GTL Business
- Growth continues despite drought News
- South Canterbury DHB pledges support for patient safety News
- Minister marks World Refugee Day News
- 244,000 smokers received help to quit News
- Court of Appeal Judge appointed News
Gordon Campbell on the incentive payments at ACC
by Gordon Campbell
The chances of achieving culture change at the Accident Compansation Corporation would seem to be almost zero if those in charge of the organisation cannot see that when you create a system of paying staff a bonus to cull ACC claimants, then this payment just might conceivably cloud their clinical judgement. That’s what bribes are meant to do – to achieve a pre-determined outcome. The desired outcome here is pretty clear. It is to tip people off ACC and into the category of being a job seeker, where they are likely to receive a lesser payment on welfare.
The corruption of the ACC scheme appears to be systemic. Not only case managers on the front lines, but team leaders, technical claims managers and branch managers also qualify for the incentive payments. On RNZ this morning, outgoing ACC chief executive Ralph Stewart stressed that the payments are only a small part of the remuneration package – but that is hardly re-assuring, or convincing. After all, surely an incentive payment has to be big enough to influence performance. That’s why it exists. In an ACC context, where clinically assessed assessment is supposed to be the determining factor in decision making, there is no place whatsoever for payments that threaten to skew the process.
Everyone, it seems, but ACC Minister Judith Collins can see the potential for abuse here. According to Stewart, ACC has two goals: to rehabilitate claimants and to manage its finances, and those two things are kept entirely separate. Ah-huh. Nothing is to be read – apparently - into the existence of the incentive scheme for the past three years, and the way the numbers of long term claimants have plunged over that period. Back in the real world though, the findings of say, the NZ Herald, appear considerably more credible:
In 2010 and again this year, the Herald ran a series of articles about the ACC's hard line with claimants, particularly those making claims for surgery. During the series, more than 400 people complained about their ACC cases. Some lawyers and independent orthopaedic surgeons criticised ACC over its crackdown on surgery access.
They alleged it relied on brief, weak opinions from its doctors, some of whom had retired from treating patients and were often not specialists in the areas they advised on.
That kind of thing – the systematic denial of entitlements – is the core problem with ACC. In the name of cost cutting, a culture has been fostered that treats long term ACC claimants as malingerers. They are not. They have been the victims of accidents and the payment they receive is not a welfare handout – it is compensation for (a) an ongoing condition that may always prevent them from going back to work and for (b) agreeing to forego the right they otherwise had to sue for damages. ACC claimants have agreed not to pursue the route of suing for compensation in return for the state intervening, and providing an adequate level of compensation. The state is now not only welshing on its side of the contract – it is paying enforcers to help them to do so.
Can Judith Collins be relied on to clean out this perverse organization, and get it back on track? Clearly not. As she already shown with the Bronwyn Pullar case, Collins doesn’t seem to grasp the issues at stake. In her view, the main concern raised by the Pullar case was poor communication practices by ACC, and not a culture of denial when it comes to entitlements. With these incentive payments, she seems similarly unable to get it. The incentive payments “are a good thing” she says, if they get people back to work. “I don't see any problem with that, but where I do see a problem is if anyone's being forced off ACC when they're simply not able to work, and I think that's a different thing altogether,” Really? So if you pay case managers and their supervisors to terminate client entitlements – because that saves the organization money - and then lo, that outcome eventuates and people go off the books, we are supposed to believe these things are entirely unrelated? C’mon. That’s not just corrupt, it’s insulting.
20 Jun 2013 Education
The Times Higher Education Publication of the Second Annual Times Higher Education 100 under 50 Ranking - Australia emerges... more
20 Jun 2013 Business News
Article - BusinessDesk NZ seeks all-of-government banking proposals in first contract shakeup since 2004 June 20... more
20 Jun 2013 Business News
Article - BusinessDesk Solid Energy leaves Mataura briquette plant operations with GTL Energy By Paul McBeth June 20 ... more
19 Jun 2013 Entertainment
NZ Music Commission Outward Sound Recipients Round 2 2013 Outward Sound is pleased to announce the 2nd round of grant recipients for... more
19 Jun 2013 Property
Call to ban foreign buyers or impose tax on top of property sale price. Australians are contributing to New Zealand's skyrocketing... more
18 Jun 2013 Migration
David Blaker says the predicted 'extra million' residents by 2030 is highly exaggerated. Debate over Auckland's future has presented... more
19 Jun 2013 Travel & Tourism
Air New Zealand’s Premium Economy Class has taken top honours overnight at the prestigious 2013 Skytrax World... more
Travelers Down Under Have More Freedom to Explore the South Pacific with the Air New Zealand Explorer Pass
18 Jun 2013 Travel & Tourism
20 Jun 2013 Sport
Winter Games NZ Audi quattro signs its name to the Games Audi New Zealand is proud to announce its naming rights sponsorship of the... more
14 Jun 2013 Opinion
Column - Gordon Campbell Gordon Campbell on why everyone has a stake in surveillance reduction In a week dominated by... more
12 Jun 2013 Column
Before I became Editor for NZNewsUK, I had the fantastic opportunity as the Location Coordinator for the Hollywood Blockbuster movie,... more
16 Jun 2013 People
The composer who wrote music for the royal wedding has written a lullaby for the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge's baby, to be sung by... more
19 Jun 2013 Recruitment
A variety of factors mean Auckland and Christchurch will be the hubs of economic growth over the next few years