How TPP affects NZ artists   29 Feb 2012

How TPP affects NZ artists and what the US wants our police to do next

Last week the CFF attended a Stakeholders Briefing on the Trans Pacific Partnership (TPP), a treaty that will affect copyright in New Zealand, the United States and other nations. New Zealanders have just spent in excess of $600,000 to develop an enforcement regime (apparently for the benefit of Rhianna) in the Infringing File Sharing Act, but more changes are on the way that affect public and artistic rights.

Summary of TPP copyright issues

1. The negotiations continue to be secretive even by WIPO standards. Some documents won’t be released for at least four years after the agreement is signed.

2. The US are pushing for New Zealand to adopt:

• Internet termination for households, businesses, and organisations;

• A policy for the NZ Police to prioritise copyright enforcement even at the detriment of other police work;

• The effective removal of Fair Dealing rights by expanding the protectionism of DRM/TPMs, including criminalising the bypassing of DRM/TPMs when exercising legal rights;

• Allowing copyright holders the ability to ban parallel imports of copyrighted material (eg DVDs), denying New Zealanders the right to purchase overseas content;

• An expansion of copyright duration to: death of the author plus 70 years, or 105 years from date of publishing for sound recordings and film.


The TPP is an international trade agreement currently being negotiated by NZ, the US, Australia, Chile, and several other pacific nations. It’s been described as a bill of rights for corporations, but this comes at a cost for artistic rights and wider public rights.

Through this process the New Zealand government is keen to build and maintain it’s political ties with the US, hoping to gain better access to US markets for it’s agricultural industry. Further down the line, New Zealand hopes that such an agreement would be joined by other big and valuable players (Japan, India etc). The US believes that it will protect a major export of theirs: copyright.

The next round of negotiations are happening in Melbourne in early March and there is a push to conclude negotiations by the end of this year. Depending on the timing of TPPA negations wrapping up, New Zealand may delay its 2013 review of the copyright act in order to first focus on the TPP.


Texts for the intellectual property chapter in the TPP have been proposed by several nations. In 2011 earlier proposals from the US, NZ and Chile were leaked.


TPP is of concern to New Zealand artists for several reasons:

1. Secrecy

As with ACTA – which is currently being met with significant criticism and protest in Europe – this treaty is being negotiated behind closed doors. Prior to entering negotiations the NZ government and all other participants signed up to a confidentiality agreement that will keep all discussion documents secret until four years after the agreement is either entered in to, or negotiations cease.

In the past US officials have made extraordinary assertions such as claiming a direct link between copyright infringement online and the funding of terrorism. These allegations have never been substantiated, however if they were introduced in a discussion document the lack of public scrutiny could see them go unchallenged throughout the negotiations. There is a significant inability for affected stakeholders and experts, such as NZ artists, to comment on the treaty with accuracy and in depth without having access these documents.

2. Copyright, copyright, copyright

The TPP text includes a significant chapter on “IP”, with particular emphasis on copyright.
Two alternative models are being discussed for this chapter:

1. the NZ/Chile proposed model which is moderate and basically seeks to uphold existing TRIPS agreements and focus on cooperation; and

2. the US model (referred to as “ACTA Plus” and the “standard US template”).

As seen in ACTA, and other US-endeavours to influence NZ copyright lawmaking, the US are pushing for aggressive and heavy-handed copyright regimes.

This has huge potential to harm the way New Zealand artists work and use the internet to connect with overseas markets. It has the potential to unfairly harm public rights and respect for copyright, artists and their work. Because copying occurs in private homes on private internet connections it’s essential to have publicly respectable copyright law, because laws that don’t earn public respect ultimately harm artists.

Items of particular note in the US proposal include:

Internet termination as a penalty;

• Requiring NZ to prioritise copyright enforcement over other matters such as police time, even at the detriment of other policing (lack of resources wouldn’t be accepted as an excuse). Some violent offenses won’t be considered as important as kinds of copyright infringement. When put alongside the $600,000 that New Zealanders have already subsidised for copyright enforcement it’s clear that the trend is to 1) make everything a criminal offense and nothing a civil offense in order to 2) pass expenses for their current business model to the public by making police enforce copyright;

• Removing Fair Dealing rights through expanding protectionism for Technical Protection Measures (TPMs) also called Digital Restriction Management (DRM), and making it a crime to bypass DRM/TPMs, for example trying to access content legally purchased from other regions by breaking the DRM on a DVD player to make it region free. This is currently legal under existing NZ copyright law and is important for enabling NZ to engage with other parts of the world. CFF is opposed to DRM protectionism;

• Allowing copyright holders to ban parallel imports of copyrighted material to allow for market segmentation (Eg expanding region coding-style systems, preventing NZers ordering books from foreign suppliers like New Zealand already lacks legal alternatives such as Hulu and Netflix — why make it harder to buy?;

• A significant extension of copyright term from death of the author plus 70 years, or 105 years from date of publishing for sound recordings and film (the NZ term is currently death of the author plus 50 years, or 50 years from date of publishing for sound recordings and film);

• Increasing civil punishments (statutory or triple damages) and ensuring mandatory sentences that remove the current right of a New Zealand judge to use their personal discretion.

Heavy handed regimes like this can have a “chilling effect” on innovation and creativity because they create massive risks for anything that touches copyright, including new artistic works, and they remove public rights in favour of copyright (such as the effective removal of Fair Dealing under the proposed changes to DRM/TPMs).

What can you do?

Write: to your MP, Minister Amy Adams and Minister Steven Joyce to explain your concerns about the TPP, and in particular these points:

• the secrecy and lack of discussion documents being made public. Nations involved in ACTA were persuaded to release the discussion documents due to significant public complaint about the private nature of this negotiation, and the same may be possible with TPP;

• the extremist US proposal, “ACTA Plus”;

• the banning of parallel importing. New Zealand already suffers from the lack of access to legal content stores online. A further removal of our access to content will isolate us from participating in global culture;

• the issue of increasing DRM protectionism effectively removing public rights that we currently have under Fair Dealing laws.

Support us: we are a not-for-profit organisation running primarily on volunteer energy. Help us keep doing what we do by donating to the CFF.

Spread the word: tell your friends about this, either in person or through social media. Like the CFF Facebook page or follow us on Twitter. Use the hashtag #tppa on Twitter when talking about it.

Find out more about the TPP

Tech Liberty

NZ Rise

TV3 blog on the TPP

TPP Watch

Ministry of Foreign Affairs & Trade

A final word

(Creative Freedom Foundation)

Add a comment

Bookmark and Share


PM welcomes closer partnership with ASEAN

22 Nov 2015 News
New Zealand Government Rt Hon John Key Prime Minister 22 November 2015   PM welcomes closer partnership with ASEAN Prime ... more

Submissions open for United Nations report

20 Nov 2015 News
Minister for Women Louise Upston welcomes public consultation on a draft report for the United Nations outlining New Zealand’s... more


Increased Canterbury quake costs pushed Tower into the red

20 Nov 2015 Business News By Paul McBeth
Nov. 20 (BusinessDesk) - Tower, the general insurer, says it will report an annual loss next week after raising its provisioning for... more

NZ inflation expectations drift further below 2% mid-point

17 Nov 2015 Business News
Article - BusinessDesk   NZ inflation expectations drift further below 2% mid-point Nov. 17 (BusinessDesk) - Longer term ... more


Awards recognise NZ recreation's top performers

20 Nov 2015 Lifestyle
New Zealand’s recreation industry recognised 10 inspiring individuals and organisations at the New Zealand Recreation ... more

Villa Maria Proves a Huge Hit

16 Nov 2015 Lifestyle
VILLA MARIA PROVES A HUGE HIT TO OPEN SOVEREIGN TRI SERIES The Sovereign Tri Series for 2015/16 is underway with today’s... more


Auckland house price growth slows in Oct as new rules bite

4 Nov 2015 Property By Tina Morrison
  Auckland house price growth moderates in October as new rules introduced Nov. 4 (BusinessDesk) - Auckland house price growth... more

Tenancy bond system moves online

1 Nov 2015 Property
New Zealand Government 1 November 2015 A new tenancy bond service goes online today as part of the Government’s programme of... more


New migrant service launched for New Zealand and Australia

12 Oct 2015 Migration
Those looking for a sense of security when immigrating to New Zealand or Australia, need look no futher than the first inusrance... more

NZ's annual net migration reaches record 60,300 in August

21 Sep 2015 Migration
  NZ's annual net migration reaches record 60,300 in August on Indian, Chinese students By Jonathan Underhill Sept. 21... more


Australia's cloud passports only "conceptual" for now: DIA

29 Oct 2015 Travel & Tourism By Fiona Rotherham
Internal Affairs says Australia's cloud passports only "conceptual" for now   Oct. 29 (BusinessDesk) - The Department of... more

Auckland Airport a 'conductor' for New Zealand tourism: CEO

22 Oct 2015 Travel & Tourism By Fiona Rotherham
  Auckland Airport a 'conductor' for New Zealand tourism, CEO Littlewood says Oct. 22 (BusinessDesk) - Auckland International... more


Richie McCaw retires from rugby

19 Nov 2015 Sport
New Zealand Rugby Union Richie McCaw retires from rugby Richie McCaw has today confirmed he is hanging up his boot... more

Burling and Tuke on top at the mid-way mark

19 Nov 2015 Sailing
Yachting New Zealand Burling and Tuke on top at the mid-way mark at 49er World Champs Peter Burling and Blair Tuke have taken the... more


Gordon Campbell on why IS’s weakness makes it more dangerous

20 Nov 2015 Opinion By Gordon Campbell
Gordon Campbell on why Islamic State’s growing weakness makes it more dangerous One of the great things about writing online... more

Gordon Campbell on Islam and the Paris attacks

17 Nov 2015 Opinion By Gordon Campbell
According to polls, a third of Republican voters in Iowa want Islam to be criminalized. Unfortunately, the c... more

Kiwi Success

Cavalier promotes CFO Paul Alston to top job

20 Nov 2015 Appointments
Article - BusinessDesk   Cavalier promotes CFO Paul Alston to top job By Paul McBeth Nov. 20 (BusinessDesk) - Cavalier Corp, the... more

Employment Court Judge appointed

20 Nov 2015 Appointments
New Zealand Government Hon Christopher FinlaysonAttorney-General 20 November 2015 Kerry Smith, barrister and solicitor of... more


UPDATE: Weaker employment adds to rate-cut case

4 Nov 2015 Recruitment By Johnathan Underhill
Article - BusinessDesk   UPDATE: NZ employment falls in third quarter, adding to case for further RBNZ rate cut (Recasts to... more

Unemployment rises 0.1 per cent

4 Nov 2015 Recruitment
The latest Household Labour Force Survey (HLFS) has reflected the softening of the economy in the first half of the year, with an... more