UPDATE: Fonterra considers options after losing supply case 1 Dec 2015
Related articles
- NZ consumers grow more upbeat, may resume spending Business
- Knowles quits as CEO of KiwiBank Business
- NZ migration bolstered by British invasion Migration
- Sludge Report #192: The Naked Budget Columns
- Budget 2010 – Building the Recovery News
- NZ manufacturing activity reaches highest since 04 Business
- NZ dollar hits 22-month high vs euro Business
- Unemployment rate falls from 7.1 to 6 percent Recruitment
- OceanaGold finds new gold deposits at Fraser mine Business
- Transpower gets go-ahead for $170m SI upgrade Business
UPDATE: Fonterra considers options, including appeal, after losing supply contract case
(Adds Fonterra reaction to judgment)
By Fiona Rotherham
Dec. 1 (BusinessDesk) - Fonterra Cooperative Group is considering its options, including an appeal, after losing a High Court case taken by former suppliers to the failed New Zealand Dairies milk processing plant at Studholme who challenged the legality of inferior supply contracts they were offered by the dairy giant.
The nub of the case was whether Fonterra, which bought the Studholme plant from the receivers in 2012, was lawfully able to offer the former suppliers to the plant so-called “growth contracts” on inferior terms in order to placate its existing farmer suppliers.
In a written decision out today, Justice Matthew Muir said Fonterra’s reasons for doing so stemmed from a “perceived need to assuage internal politics within its supplier base and included also an element of ‘messaging’ for the benefit of other farmers who might in the future be persuaded to leave Fonterra and support an independent.”
Mike Cronin, Fonterra’s group director governance and legal, said the cooperative was disappointed with the outcome and was now reviewing the reasoning as well as the implications of the decision.
“The judgment refers to complex and difficult issues about special contracts with farmers outside the co-op,” he said.” Fonterra’s acquisition of the former NZDL plant benefited both Fonterra and the supplying farmers who’d been left out of pocket by NZ Dairies, enabling significant retro-payments owed to them to be paid and ensuring on-going milk collection.”
The former NZ Dairies suppliers were owed more than $20 million for the previous season’s milk from the receivers and Fonterra’s $50 million offer to the receivers to buy the failed Studholme plant was conditional on all of them signing the six-year supply contracts. The farmers wouldn't have been paid in full for the retro-payments under alternative offers.
Fonterra told the court it was lawfully entitled to offer the interior contracts, which included a five cents per kilogram of milk solids price discount and a one-year bar on buying shares, despite provisions under the Dairy Industry Restructuring Act that require new entrants to be treated on the same terms as existing shareholder suppliers.
The court decision comes as the Commerce Commission seeks submissions this month on its draft report on the state of competition in New Zealand’s dairy industry which found that Fonterra could charge too much for its milk if the industry is deregulated. It found there was still insufficient competition at both the farmgate and factory gate to fully remove the DIRA regime.
The High Court case included claims under the Fair Trading Act and the Contractual Remedies Act arising from statements allegedly made by Fonterra representatives at various meetings before the 20 plaintiffs - dairy farmers in south Canterbury and Otago, signed the growth contracts.
The judgement cited Kelvin Wickham, now Fonterra’s managing director Global Ingredients, in an internal email saying that the former NZDL shareholders shouldn't be allowed to “share up” (buy shares against their production) until potentially the end of the first year so there is a “differential milk price penalty for at least a year – they can’t just expect to waltz back in and get full milk price if they share up”.
The plaintiffs argued the fact Fonterra was able to make a “take it or leave it” offer and impose “penalties” for essentially internal political purposes was evidence of an uncompetitive market for milk supply.
Fonterra’s defence was that the DIRA clause on treatment of new entrants only applied to share-backed supply and it wasn’t precluded from offering special terms for contract supply.
Justice Muir said he had difficulty with the plaintiff’s argument conferring them new entrant status but he found Fonterra couldn’t treat an applicant outside of the stated application period for supply as a new entrant for some of their supply and not the balance, essentially creating a subcategory of new entrants with inferior rights.
“Fonterra retains a discretion in terms of whether it accepts such entrants into the shareholding farmer “fold” but why, having elected to do so, it should be able to discriminate against the individuals concerned in a way not possible in respect of timely applicants seems to be a proposition which struggles for a basis in principle,” he said.
The judge accepted the plaintiffs argument that no factors provided justification for a difference in terms and he also concluded that Fonterra breached the Fair Trading Act and the Contractual Remedies Act by giving an overriding impression to the new suppliers that the reason they weren’t being allowed to share up was because they were outside the application period.
“The overall message was that the suppliers were not being treated differently from other Growth Contact suppliers in relation to sharing up when in fact they were,” he said.
A further hearing is to be held to determine what losses the plaintiffs have incurred and the question of legal costs.
(BusinessDesk)
News
Hilary Timmins' Award-Winning UK Documentary Series To Inspire NZ Students
29 Jun 2020 Education
Dream Catchers, produced and directed by Hilary Timmins, celebrates the success stories of more than thirty inspirational New... more
New Zealand reaffirms support for Flight MH17 judicial process
7 Mar 2020 News
Ahead of the start of the criminal trial in the Netherlands on 9 March, Foreign Minister Winston Peters has reaffirmed the need to... more
Business
NZ Government's Economic package to fight COVID-19
17 Mar 2020 Business News
The Coalition Government has launched the most significant peace-time economic plan in modern New Zealand history to cushion the... more
NZ Government announces aviation relief package
19 Mar 2020 Business News
Transport Minister Phil Twyford today outlined the first tranche of the $600 million aviation sector relief package announced earlier... more
Living
Diversity was Key at New Zealand Trade Tasting in London
6 Jun 2022 Food & Wine
New Zealand Winegrowers Annual Trade Tasting was recently held in London, on Wednesday 4 May, in Lindley Hall.
It was the first... more
Kiwi author stuns Behind the Butterfly Gate
12 Jan 2022 Arts
Hidden behind the Butterfly Gate is where the secret has been kept for 76 years...
New Zealand writer Merryn Corcoran’s... more
Property
Fairer rules for tenants and landlords
17 Nov 2019 Property
17 NOVEMBER 2019
The Government has delivered on its promise to the over one million New Zealanders who now rent to make it fairer... more
New Zealand Government will not implement a Capital Gains Tax
17 Apr 2019 Property
The Coalition Government will not proceed with the Tax Working Group’s recommendation for a capital gains tax, Jacinda Ardern... more
Migration
Boosting border security with electronic travel authority – now over 500,000 issued
19 Nov 2019 Migration
19 NOVEMBER 2019
We’ve improved border security with the NZeTA, New Zealand Electronic Travel Authority, which helps us to... more
Christchurch reinstated as refugee settlement location
18 Aug 2018 Migration
18 AUGUST 2018
HON IAIN LEES-GALLOWAY
The announcement that Christchurch can once again be a settlement location for refugees... more
Travel
Gallipoli Anzac Day services cancelled
19 Mar 2020 Travel & Tourism
The New Zealand and Australian Governments have announced this year’s joint Anzac Day services at Gallipoli will be cancelled... more
New Zealanders advised not to travel overseas
19 Mar 2020 Travel & Tourism
New Zealanders advised not to travel overseas
more
Sport
The Skipper's Diary: Sir Richard Hadlee honouring his father and NZ's Forty-Niners
27 Oct 2019 Cricket
NZNewsUK London Editor Charlotte Everett spoke to Sir Richard Hadlee about why he’s chosen to publish his father’s... more
PREVIEW: All Blacks v England semi-final
26 Oct 2019 Rugby
The two most convincing quarterfinals winners are set to square off in a semifinal showdown for the ages when the All Blacks meet old... more
Columns
Gordon Campbell on the Gareth Morgan crusade
11 Nov 2016 Opinion
Gordon Campbell on the Gareth Morgan crusade
First published on Werewolf
The ghastly likes of Marine Le Pen in France and Geert ... more
Gordon Campbell on the US election outcome
10 Nov 2016 Opinion
Column - Gordon Campbell
Gordon Campbell on the US election outcome
Well um.. on the bright side, there (probably)... more
Kiwi Success
Congratulations to Loder Cup winner
26 Sep 2018 People
25 SEPTEMBER 2018
The Loder Cup, one of New Zealand’s oldest conservation awards, has been awarded to Robert McGowan for 2018... more
Appointments to New Zealand National Commission for UNESCO
16 Aug 2018 Appointments
16 AUGUST 2018Appointments to New Zealand National Commission for UNESCO
HON JENNY SALESA
Associate Education Minister Jenny Salesa is... more
Recruitment
Historic pay equity settlement for education support workers
14 Aug 2018 Recruitment
14 AUGUST 2018Historic pay equity settlement for education support workers
RT HON JACINDA ARDERN
HON CHRIS HIPKINS
Prime Minister
The... more
Historic pay equity settlement for education support workers
22 Aug 2018 Recruitment
14 AUGUST 2018Historic pay equity settlement for education support workers
RT HON JACINDA ARDERN
HON CHRIS HIPKINS
Prime Minister
The... more