Transport and local govt reforms at odds over 'well-beings' 14 Sep 2012
- MARKET CLOSE: NZX 50 falls, led by Sky TV on football rival Business
- Wynyard shares to list near bottom of range, at $1.15 Business
- Online start-up seeks rapid uptake of English football Business
- NZ dollar almost unchanged as traders await Fed Business
- ‘Lean with us’ tour to support America’s Cup challenge Sport
- Motorcycle Safety Advisory Council Chair appointed News
- RBNZ eyes holes in payment system supervision Business
- Coordinated winter resilience programme rolled out News
- NZCPR-Weekly A Two-Tier Society News
- MPs privilege vital against Hanover-style suits, Parker says Business
Transport and local govt amendments at odds over status of 'well-beings'
By Jonathan Underhill
Sept. 14 (BusinessDesk) - An overhaul of the aims of local government, stripping its role back to core functions, may require changes to the Land Transport Management Act (LTMA) which contain similar, lofty aspirations for kiwis’ social, cultural and environmental wellbeing.
The Local Government Act Amendment Bill would remove councils’ requirement to consider their citizens’ "social, economic, cultural and environmental well-being" in a move aimed at curbing hikes to rates and services charges. The Cabinet agreed to the new purpose in March. The bill is before select committee at present, and faces opposition from local governments.
“Both Acts deal with allocation of land transport funding and some degree of alignment in their purposes is desirable,” Greg Mossong, principal adviser at the Ministry of Transport, says in the covering note for a regulatory impact statement (RIS) for the LTMA review.
Central and local government overlap on land transport because they both contribute – about $3 billion a year from government and $1.5 billion from local authorities. Transport Minister Gerry Brownlee says the Land Transport Management Amendment Bill is aimed at streamlining the funding processes and cutting red tape.
The LTMA’s current purpose is to “contribute to the aim of achieving an affordable, integrated, safe, responsive and sustainable land transport system.” But in May last year, the Cabinet agreed to change the purpose to “contribute to an effective, efficient and safe land transport system that supports New Zealand’s economic, social, cultural and environmental wellbeing.”
“The proposed changes to the Local Government Act purpose agreed by Cabinet in March 2012 do not align well with the proposed Land Transport Management Act changes agreed in May 2011, the RIS says.
The Ministry of Transport consulted widely with other government departments on four options to tweak the LTMA amendments. Feedback from the Ministry for the Environment and Ministry of Health was that transport has wider impacts beyond economic efficiency and the purpose of the LTMA should include reference to environmental, social and health objectives.
The preferred option in the RIS is to change the wording in the purpose of the LTMA amendment so that it refers to “the public interest” rather than the wider reference to “wellbeings”.
“The values embedded in the term ‘wellbeings’ have proven controversial and the government is moving away from that term in the local government context,” the RIS says.
The Ministry of Transport didn’t support an option that would make the wording of the LTMA similar to the local government amendment of providing core functions “at the least possible cost to households and business.” That’s because it “lacks sufficient reference to the wider impacts of land transport investment on society,” overlooks the concept of safety and “does not adequately recognise the nature of the rationing decisions needed in allocating a limited pool of land transport resources,” the RIS says.
Many submissions on the Local Government Act 2002 Amendment Bill also question whether similar proposed changes to definitions are clear enough in their intent.
Parliament’s local government and environment committee is currently considering the local government bill, which had its first reading in June, and is due to report back on Nov. 5.
The Land Transport Management Amendment Bill 2012 was introduced to Parliament on Aug. 13 and is expected to pass into law in the first half of 2013.
19 Jun 2013 News
New Zealand Government Hon Chris TremainMinister of Internal Affairs 19 June 2013 Package of reforms planned for Class... more
19 Jun 2013 Business News
Article - BusinessDesk Dairy product prices halt slide in GDT auction, rise 1.1% June 19 (BusinessDesk) - Prices of dairy ... more
19 Jun 2013 Business News
Article - BusinessDesk AMP Capital NZ lifts FY fee income by 34% on Axa inflows, stronger markets June 18 (BusinessDesk)... more
19 Jun 2013 Entertainment
NZ Music Commission Outward Sound Recipients Round 2 2013 Outward Sound is pleased to announce the 2nd round of grant recipients for... more
19 Jun 2013 Property
Call to ban foreign buyers or impose tax on top of property sale price. Australians are contributing to New Zealand's skyrocketing... more
18 Jun 2013 Migration
David Blaker says the predicted 'extra million' residents by 2030 is highly exaggerated. Debate over Auckland's future has presented... more
18 Jun 2013 Migration
Moving to New Zealand means moving to a beautiful country with a wealth of opportunity. New Zealand has 6000 kilometers of coast... more
19 Jun 2013 Travel & Tourism
Air New Zealand’s Premium Economy Class has taken top honours overnight at the prestigious 2013 Skytrax World... more
Travelers Down Under Have More Freedom to Explore the South Pacific with the Air New Zealand Explorer Pass
18 Jun 2013 Travel & Tourism
19 Jun 2013 Rugby
British and Irish Lions wing more
14 Jun 2013 Opinion
Column - Gordon Campbell Gordon Campbell on why everyone has a stake in surveillance reduction In a week dominated by... more
12 Jun 2013 Column
Before I became Editor for NZNewsUK, I had the fantastic opportunity as the Location Coordinator for the Hollywood Blockbuster movie,... more
16 Jun 2013 People
The composer who wrote music for the royal wedding has written a lullaby for the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge's baby, to be sung by... more
19 Jun 2013 Recruitment
A variety of factors mean Auckland and Christchurch will be the hubs of economic growth over the next few years