Commerce Commission takes ‘extreme’ positions on telco rules   15 Jun 2012

Article - BusinessDesk

Commerce Commission taking ‘extreme’ positions on telco regulation

By Pattrick Smellie

June 15 (BusinessDesk) - New Zealand is gaining an international reputation for "extreme" and unpredictable regulation by its competition watchdog, the Commerce Commission, says Andrew Bascand, managing director of fund manager Harbour Asset Management.

In a submission to the telecommunications commissioner, Ross Patterson, Bascand says the commission's approach puts the success of the government's ultra-fast broadband initiative at risk, and could be a turn-off for foreign investors considering buying shares in partially privatised state-owned energy companies.

His comments follow what he describes as last month's "policy shock" of draft regulations for the unbundled copper local loop - the traditional mainstay infrastructure of the national telephone system, which fibre-optic cable will replace as ultra-fast broadband rolls out nationwide.

The government's $1.5 billion subsidy plan is intended to accelerate uptake of UFB, but the Commerce Commission's approach suggests it "has a mandate to tilt the playing field back to copper," while using a flawed benchmarking approach to regulation, Bascand said.

"Telco industry regulation needs to have a policy anchor that is consistent across a broad range of objectives involving customer outcomes, the allocation of capital, and the recognition of the benefits to society in the move to fibre that may not just be consumer-related, he said.

"Regulated returns need to have a cost of capital framework, not a benchmarking framework," said Bascand.

While releasing draft regulations for consultation was a good practice, "some market participants observe that the commission seems to take an extreme position initially on some issues."

That raised risk premiums for investors at odds with the commission's role as a "core player" in New Zealand's capital markets.

The commission's drafts appeared to adopt tactical positions "to be used as a bargaining tool with companies", or to allow it conduct "goal-seeking exercises."

Bascand said if a benchmarking approach had to be used, it would make most sense to use the agreed price for basic UFB service of $37.50 a month, since that had been "tested in the real world through a long, robust and hard-negotiated tender process" overseen by Crown Fibre Holdings.

Telecom, which split off its infrastructure unit Chorus earlier this year to participate in the UFB roll-out, won the lion's share of the UFB funding in a process that policymakers were anxious to ensure did not force pricing for copper-based serviced to fall so far that uptake of UFB stalled.

However, last month's draft decision had led Goldman Sachs to cut its forecast of UFB uptake by 10 percent, suggesting outcomes that "run entirely counter to government policy", tilting the playing field in favour of copper and forcing Chorus to accept uneconomic returns on its copper network.

However the issue was handled, the government should be aware international investors now look askance at New Zealand regulators, making them wary of investing in partially privatised assets where regulatory risk remains high, such as the electricity sector.

"The government should contemplate legislation to ensure Chorus earns an appropriate return on their entire copper network and settles this matter before they embark on talking to global investors about IPOs of the SOEs," Bascand told Patterson. "Our recommendation is to set aside the UCLL and all other copper based investigations pending the full telco sector review."

While the review was scheduled for 2016, enough evidence of UFB uptake may have emerged in time for it to be held a year earlier instead.


Add a comment

Bookmark and Share


English to IMF and World Bank this week

5 Oct 2015 News
New Zealand Government Hon Bill English Minister of Finance 5 October 2015 Media Statement English to IMF and World Bank this... more

Six banks awarded All-of-Government contracts

5 Oct 2015 News
5 October 2015   Six banks awarded All-of-Government contracts Minister of Finance Bill English and Economic Development... more


NZ government seeks to double private sector R&D by 2025

5 Oct 2015 Business News
Article - BusinessDesk   NZ govt science plan seeks to double private sector R&D by 2025 By Paul McBeth Oct. 5... more

NZX 50 books worst quarter since 2012 amid global fears

2 Oct 2015 Business News By Suze Metherell
  NZX 50 books worst quarter since 2012, as global fears weigh on stocks Oct. 2 (BusinessDesk) - New Zealand stocks booked... more


Popularity of new guide fuelled by pedal power

28 Sep 2015 Lifestyle
New Zealand Automobile Association Media Release: 28 September 2015 Popularity of new guide fuelled by pedal power New Zealanders... more

Whittaker’s ‘unbeatable’ as NZ’s most loved brand

21 Sep 2015 Food & Wine
The All Blacks may have a shot of becoming the first team ever to win consecutive Rugby World Cups but they can’t top a... more


Chinese property investors disappearing from the auction room

28 Sep 2015 Property
Chinese property investors are rapidly disappearing from the auction room, says the boss of Auckland's biggest real estate... more

Auckland house sales climb to 15-yr high for month of August

3 Sep 2015 Property By Paul McBeth
Article - BusinessDesk   Auckland house sales climb to 15-year high for month of August, prices stall Sept. 3 (BusinessDesk) -... more


NZ's annual net migration reaches record 60,300 in August

21 Sep 2015 Migration
  NZ's annual net migration reaches record 60,300 in August on Indian, Chinese students By Jonathan Underhill Sept. 21... more

NZ – Filipino Arrangement on migrant workers

18 Sep 2015 Migration
New Zealand Government NZ – Filipino Arrangement on migrant workers Workplace Relations and Safety and Immigration Minister... more


Winter holiday makers drive visitor growth

28 Sep 2015 Travel & Tourism
An increase in overseas visitors seeking a winter break resulted in an additional 10,000 holiday arrivals to New Zealand in August, as... more

Smartpay forecasts second year of earnings decline

8 Sep 2015 Travel & Tourism
Article - BusinessDesk   Smartpay forecasts second year of earnings decline By Tina Morrison Sept. 8 (BusinessDesk) - Smartpay... more


Silver Ferns trials underway

5 Oct 2015 Netball
Trials are underway in Auckland for the Silver Ferns team to contest the New World Netball Series for Constellation Cup. The lure... more

Two of NZ football’s greatest players are to be honoured

5 Oct 2015 Football
Two of New Zealand football’s greatest players are to be honoured by their peers at a celebratory dinner in Auckland next... more


Gordon Campbell on the TPP countdown, & Mary Margaret O’Hara

5 Oct 2015 Opinion
Column - Gordon Campbell   Gordon Campbell on the TPP countdown, and Mary Margaret O’Hara While Australia and the US have... more

Gordon Campbell on TPP dairy , and investor-state disputes

28 Sep 2015 Opinion
Column - Gordon Campbell   Gordon Campbell on New Zealand’s TPP done deal on dairy, and on investor-state disputes For... more

Kiwi Success

Fonterra director Farrelly replaces Norris on Fund board

23 Sep 2015 Appointments By Paul McBeth
Fonterra director Ian Farrelly replaces Ralph Norris on shareholders' fund board Sept. 23 (BusinessDesk) - Fonterra Cooperative... more

Honouring New Zealand’s best on and off the field

23 Sep 2015 People
As a group of special Kiwis compete for the Rugby World Cup title, Kiwibank is calling on New Zealanders right here to honour their... more


'Close to zero' chance of another bum hire: FMA's Everett

2 Oct 2015 Recruitment By Fiona Rotherham
  'Close to zero' chance of another bum hire, says FMA's Everett Oct. 2 (BusinessDesk) - Financial Markets Authority chief... more

More action needed to reduce Gender Pay Gap

2 Oct 2015 Recruitment
New Zealand Government Hon Louise Upston Minister for Women   2 October 2015 Minister for Women Louise Upston says she is... more