NZ Refining to review New Zealand's 'laziest balance sheet'   27 Apr 2012

Pattrick Smellie

New Zealand Refining’s board has promised to review its dividend policy, heading off a charge that investors bear the brunt of volatile earnings through gyrating payments and what one shareholder called “the laziest corporate balance sheet in New Zealand.”

The company that runs the nation’s only oil refinery needed small shareholder support in today’s crunch vote in Whangarei on a $365 million Continuous Catalyst Regeneration Platformer Project (CCR). The project required shareholder approval because of its size relative to NZ Refining’s market capitalisation of around $785 million.

Shareholders BP and Mobil, who hold 43 percent of the refinery’s shares, are understood to have opposed the CCR proposal, and the company mounted an unprecedented round of shareholder briefings to try to shore up a majority for the CCR.

If rejected, the refinery will still spend $105 million on a must-do upgrade to keep the refinery running past 2015.

The board’s most trenchant critic was former Contact Energy and Shell NZ director John Milne, who said it was “astonishing” that the company was in its 50th year of operation and “still has no dividend policy.” He criticised its policy of carrying almost no debt on its balance sheet.

Reduced dividends were identified as a major concern by other small shareholders, who depended on share income to meet living expenses.

However, chairman David Jackson appeared to expect the attack, announcing in his general remarks the board would later this year review the optimal gearing for the company, whose policy has been to completely repay debt raised for major projects at the expense of dividends.

While deleveraging had been prudent during the global financial crisis, the board and management would consider “whether this is appropriate for the long-term structure of the company.”

The review would be undertaken this year.

The touch and go vote occurred at 2pm, with a result to be announced to the NZX this afternoon. NZ Refining shares remain in trading halt in the meantime, having last traded at $2.75.

Craigs Investment Partners said in analysis this week the CCR option was the better of the two options, although it would prefer there was an option for delay, and warned there was no guarantee dividends would return to normal levels before 2020.

Milne said even though the company had substantial retained earnings, the board treated the payment of dividends as “purely discretionary.” Jackson, in turn, described NZ Refining as “highly cash-generative” despite the volatile impact of swings in global refining margins and the exchange rate on its profitability.

Milne also accused the board of failing to act transparently by refusing to reveal how many of the directors representing oil companies had opposed the CCR project, and to allow one of as many as four directors to explain to shareholders why they had objected.

Jackson would not allow such disclosures, saying communication should be directed through the chair and chief executive.

(BusinessDesk)

Add a comment

Bookmark and Share

News

Body found in London park believed to be missing Kiwi

30 Sep 2014 News
London police believe a body found in a southwest London park is that of missing New Zealand man Malcolm McKinlay. Mr McKinlay, who... more

Uncovering the secrets of NZ's discovery

30 Sep 2014 News
Two scientific papers have shed new light on how Polynesian explorers may have arrived in New Zealand, but the authors have... more

Business

NZ dollar heads for 11% slump in Sept quarter

30 Sep 2014 Business News
By Paul McBeth Sept. 30 (BusinessDesk) - The New Zealand dollar is heading for an 11 percent slump in the September quarter as... more

Derceto purchased by French company

30 Sep 2014 Business News
A technology startup born out of professional services consultancy Beca has taken the next step in its growth. Beca has concluded an... more

Living

Louis Baker covers Prince's 'Purple Rain'

30 Sep 2014 Entertainment
  The intensity of this up close and mesmerizing intimate performance shows why Baker has become renowned for both tear... more

Hang Out With the Julie Lamb Band

30 Sep 2014 Lifestyle
Julie Lamb Celebrate the launch of Julie Lamb’s much anticipated third album, When We Hang Out, with a free live performance... more

Property

NZ building consents flatline in August

30 Sep 2014 Property
By Suze Metherell Sept. 30 (BusinessDesk) - New Zealand building consents held steady in August from a month earlier, underpinned... more

Australia's Quattro in talks to buy NZ properties

30 Sep 2014 Property
By Suze Metherell Sept. 30 (BusinessDesk) - Quattro Asset Management, an Australian fund manager, is in negotiations to buy two... more

Migration

Indefinite Leave to Remain made simple

30 Sep 2014 Migration
There are thousands of expats living in the UK who are aiming for permanent residency status and, eventually, a British passport. But... more

Migration boom rolls on as fewer kiwis depart

30 Sep 2014 Migration
New Zealand's annual net migration rose to a record in August, exceeding Treasury's forecasts, and spurred by more migrant arrivals... more

Travel

Travel tidbits and deals of the week

30 Sep 2014 Travel & Tourism
Some of the best travel deals going - both in New Zealand and abroad. Bookmark this page and check back each week for all the latest ... more

Air NZ's Luxon defends domestic regional air fares

30 Sep 2014 Travel & Tourism
By Paul McBeth Sept. 30 (BusinessDesk) - Air New Zealand chief executive Christopher Luxon has defended its pricing on domestic... more

Sport

New Zealand's Top sporting rich list

30 Sep 2014 Sport
The Herald reveals who they believe are the highest-paid New Zealand sports people and look at how they make a living on and off the ... more

Footballing Giants Real Madrid and AC Milan Kick Off in Dec

30 Sep 2014 Football
Dubai’s Department of Tourism and Commerce Marketing (DTCM) and Emirates Airline have announced that the 2014 UEFA Champions... more

Columns

Time to debate proportional representation

30 Sep 2014 Opinion
Article - Sridhar Ekambaram   Time to debate proportional representation By Sridhar Ekambaram30 September 2014 With the... more

Gordon Campbell on the farcical elevation of David Seymour

30 Sep 2014 Column
Column - Gordon Campbell   Gordon Campbell on the farcical elevation of David Seymour With the election won, it's time to find... more

Kiwi Success

Villa Maria medal haul

30 Sep 2014 People
Out of a particularly difficult vintage, Villa Maria's 2012 Hawke's Bay Reserve Syrah, is a shining star. The winery collected nine... more

Open Arms second at Pacifica Beats

30 Sep 2014 People
Months of practice was all over in just nine minutes but Rotorua Boys' High School's nine piece reggae band Open Arms have had the... more

Recruitment

NZ's top pay packet revealed: $4.1m

30 Sep 2014 Recruitment
With a total pay package worth $4.1 million, ANZ New Zealand's David Hisco is the top-paid boss in the Business Herald's executive pay... more

NZ job market expected to strengthen - survey

30 Sep 2014 Recruitment
The job market is expected to strengthen and potential employees are increasingly looking at staying in New Zealand for work instead... more